MENU

Why Phil Robertson Was Really Suspended From Duck Dynasty

December 19, 2013 • Kulturkampf, National

Phil Robertson, head of the Robertson family business featured in the show Duck Dynasty, has been suspended from the show for not being left-wing enough. He made some statements in an interview with GQ that apparently made the A&E network upset. It seems they weren’t prepared to accept that this duck hunter from Louisiana is, in fact, a real-life Southern White Christian and not simply a source of entertainment:

“Everything is blurred on what’s right and what’s wrong… Sin becomes fine,” he said. “Start with homosexual behavior and just morph out from there. Bestiality, sleeping around with this woman and that woman and that woman and those men.”

Paraphrasing Corinthians he added: “Don’t be deceived. Neither the adulterers, the idolaters, the male prostitutes, the homosexual offenders, the greedy, the drunkards, the slanderers, the swindlers—they won’t inherit the kingdom of God. Don’t deceive yourself. It’s not right.”

That’s a pretty normal Christian perspective, one that Robertson shares with millions of the other Vaisyas who watch his show. None of what he said is unusual except to the progressive Brahmins who see him not only as a foreigner but as morally inferior and in need of correction. Have a look at the show’s hashtag on Twitter and you’ll see a level of hatred towards Robertson and his thede that one rarely sees towards homosexuals. Or take this response, for instance:

The gay and lesbian rights group GLAAD was quick to criticize Robertson for his comments and called on A&E to take action.

“Phil and his family claim to be Christian, but Phil’s lies about an entire community fly in the face of what true Christians believe,” said GLAAD rep Wilson Cruz. “He clearly knows nothing about gay people or the majority of Louisianans – and Americans – who support legal recognition for loving and committed gay and lesbian couples. Phil’s decision to push vile and extreme stereotypes is a stain on A&E and his sponsors who now need to reexamine their ties to someone with such public disdain for LGBT people and families.”

Why should Phil Robertson, A&E, or anyone else give a damn about what GLAAD think? What place has a representative of a gay activist group to talk about “what true Christians believe”? He may disagree with Robertson’s notion of sin, but that isn’t enough to allow him to redefine Christianity as something less offensive to gays. Robertson’s words show him to be in line with millions of other Americans, not to mention thousands of years of religious tradition. Only a Brahmin, divorced from the cultural past, would suggest that quoting 1 Corinthians VI:9-11 is a “decision to push vile and extreme stereotypes”. It takes a special kind of arrogance to think that feeling offended qualifies you to pass judgement on age-old conventions that have stood the test of time.

Progressives, in their insistence on lockstep adherence to their ideology, are no less religious than Phil Robertson. And because they form the media-academic circuit that runs the United States, they often have the power to humiliate those who don’t at least pay lip service to progressivism. The “gay rights” issue is not about helping the three-and-a-half percent of the population who are actually gay, it’s about keeping the nonprogressive half of America in line. Perhaps Robertson knew this quite well and wanted to prove the point; this certainly isn’t the first time A&E has tried to regiment him to fit their image. You can hear him in this video discussing how the network wanted to add bleeps to the audio of the show, which did not actually contain profanity, to add “spice”, and how they removed the words “in Jesus’ name” from the family’s prayers.

Clearly, Duck Dynasty is not produced or broadcast by people who have much appreciation for the culture of the people the show is about. It may be a record-setting series in cable television, but that’s not enough for A&E. They don’t just want money; they want rigid ideological conformity. This is yet another example of how Brahmins will pass up massive amounts of money when doing otherwise would make them seem too friendly to the people they hate. In Sweden, it’s even worse; there are shows like Troll Hunters that actually target nonprogressives for humiliation. There are too many conservative Vaisyas in the United States for there to be an equivalent program here, but networks like A&E would surely enjoy being able to market one. What’s to be done when “American culture” is actually two cultures at war with one another?

Related Posts

  • ConantheContrarian

    I wonder if some other cable company would produce the show?

    • nilsm

      TV is going to be dead sooner or later. Most cable channels are only alive because the companies bundle them up with channels people actually want.

  • Erik

    The “true Christians” bit was particularly hilarious and stupid. Maybe GLAAD rep Wilson Cruz is thinking about “those five Unitarians I met one time who told me that Jesus must have been secretly gay since he never married a woman and only picked male disciples”. Sadly for him, those five Unitarians do not constitute true Christianity unless one decides to redefine “true” to mean “Progressive-approved”.

    Somewhere else:
    “Meanwhile, look at Phil Robertson. http://larrycorreia.files.wordpress.com/2013/12/robertson.png Does that man strike you as the sort of person who gives a shit?”

  • FWM

    “…the power to humiliate those who don’t at least pay lip service to
    progressivism.”

    You’re understating — in a “nation” based upon economics, threatening and removing a man’s livelihood means casting him into darkness with the dregs. I would have to use exactly one epitaph to have the full weight of the HR harpies on my back, dead set on destroying my 25 years of schooling and 15 years of “trade work,” with a righteous fury that would leave my head spinning.

    But the country needs burger flippers too…

  • ThorsMitersaw

    “qualifies you to pass judgement on age-old conventions that have stood the test of time.

    Progressives, in their insistence on lockstep adherence to their ideology”

    So when you are adhering to the rejection and out casting of homosexuals, based upon its apparent ability to perpetuate itself, you are NOT marching lockstep to your ideology?

    I agree with a lot of things on this site, but the dick sucking of Christianity and its open bigotry towards homosexuals can rot in hell. I suppose we should re institute slavery because the bible condones it? Or stoning adulterers and witches and the like?

    Tradition, ability to perpetuate itself, is not reason enough to support something existing. Famine. Disease. War. These things are awful things that have stood your test of time. Do you support death and destruction as well? Being that you have such reverence for the old as dirt conventions and plights of man?

    • AbuDhabi

      “I suppose we should re institute slavery because the bible condones it?”

      Dude, America has the biggest slave population in the world. What on Earth are you talking about?

  • BiggerFatterPolitics

    Meet Phil Robertson’s Gay Lover. Phil Robertson Outed

    Phil is a flaming homo. His gay lover has come forward. Phil blows a lot more than duck calls!

« »